Missing Jimmy’s is serving up big flavor, nostalgic charm, and one of the best happy hours in town, and Dublin locals agree. This spot is a back-to-back champ in the Visit Dublin Ohio Voters’ Choice Awards (2023 and 2024)! Whether you’re here for a casual drink after work, cheering on your favorite team, or craving a taste of Youngstown-style comfort food, Missing Jimmy’s has quickly become a Dublin favorite.
The Vibe
Missing Jimmy’s nails that perfect balance between laid-back and lively. Step inside and you’ll find cozy booths, friendly faces, and TVs tuned to the big game, it’s the kind of place where you instantly feel at home.
The theme? A nod to one of America’s most famous mysteries. Yes, that Jimmy. Missing Jimmy’s tips its hat to the legend of Jimmy Hoffa, who vanished nearly half a century ago. But instead of crime and chaos, this Dublin bar keeps things fun and nostalgic, with subtle winks to the past and a community-centered spirit that makes it unforgettable.
Created by the team behind Meatball Mafia, this spot brings a bit of Youngstown flavor, literally and figuratively, to the heart of Dublin. Expect a welcoming crowd, plenty of conversation, and an atmosphere that’s just as comfortable for a chill night out as it is for catching the next big game.
The Food
If you know Meatball Mafia, you already know you’re in for something special. Missing Jimmy’s brings the same beloved Youngstown-style pizza, meatball subs, and Italian comfort dishes that made its sister spot a local favorite.
The Large Meatball Bowl is exactly what it sounds like, five hearty, hand-rolled meatballs smothered in delicate tomato sauce, served with creamy ricotta and Italian bread for a satisfying, old-school meal.
The Wartime Consigliere levels things up with meatballs nestled in a pepperoni-lined torpedo roll, topped with provolone, mozzarella, and that signature ricotta. It’s a crave-worthy mashup of casual and classic.
And then there’s the Brier Hill Pizza, a Youngstown legend with thick, golden crust, zesty house sauce, sweet peppers, and a parmesan “lid” of melted cheese. Every bite is comforting, nostalgic, and full of flavor, proof that Missing Jimmy’s knows how to do food right.
The Drinks
Missing Jimmy’s keeps things refreshingly simple behind the bar, no overcomplicated mixology here, just good drinks done right. You’ll find classic small-town favorites on tap and plenty of canned options for those who like to keep it easy.
Happy hour is where this spot really shines. With half-off drafts Monday through Friday from 3 to 6 PM, it’s the perfect place to unwind after work or kick off your weekend early. Plus, with daily drink specials, there’s always something new to try (and a reason to come back).
While beer lovers will be more than satisfied, cocktail fans aren’t left out either. Missing Jimmy’s offers a small but mighty selection of handcrafted drinks, like the Strawberry Strike, a refreshing mix of strawberry whiskey, ginger beer, and lemonade that tastes like summer in a glass. Or try the Godfather, a smooth blend of Blue Rye whiskey, Disaronno, and bitters that’s equal parts classic and cool.
Whether you come for the food, the drinks, or just the good vibes, Missing Jimmy’s delivers that welcoming, small-town feel that makes Dublin special. With its mix of hearty comfort food, great happy hour deals, and a personality all its own, it’s easy to see why this local hangout has everyone talking.
